Learning / Delivery practice

Review Rounds for Software Projects

Review the work with a purpose.

A review round is a planned moment to compare a draft or working build with its agreed goal. It should make the next decision clearer, not become an endless stream of unrelated edits.

Read the guide

At a glance

  1. Review against a named outcome
  2. Collect one consolidated set of feedback
  3. Treat defects and new features differently

Agree what a round includes

At the start, agree which deliverables get review rounds, how many are included, who can comment and when feedback is due. A round can cover a concept, a design, a prototype or a working release candidate. Its scope should match the maturity of the work: a wireframe invites questions about flow, while a release candidate needs content and behaviour checks.

There is no universal correct number of rounds. A short page may need one clear review and a complex service may need several staged decisions. Put the actual allowance in the project agreement, along with how extra rounds are requested.

Give the team feedback it can act on

Use one place for comments and one client lead to resolve conflicting opinions. For each comment, identify the page or state, what you expected, what happened and why it matters to the user or business. Screenshots and device details help when behaviour differs across screens.

Review from the user journey outwards: can someone start, understand the choices, recover from an error and finish? Then review words, layout and visual polish. This order prevents teams from perfecting details around a journey that still needs to change.

Separate correction from expansion

A defect is work that fails an agreed acceptance criterion. A refinement changes presentation or wording within the agreed outcome. A new feature introduces an outcome, integration or user flow that was not in scope. Classifying the request before estimating it avoids talking past one another.

When the change is larger than the agreed round, record the options: replace another item, move it to a later phase or approve a variation. Keep the final decision alongside the design or ticket so it survives handover.

Close a round with a decision

End each round with a short record: accepted, accepted with listed changes, or needs another decision. Before launch, review the actual release candidate in a gated environment and confirm who will check the public version after deployment.

Sign-off should not stand in for security, accessibility or functional testing. Those checks need their own owners and evidence.

A review has done its job when the people involved can say what changed, why it changed and who accepted the result.

External project website

Open this project site?

is hosted at . It will open in a new tab.